Normally, a bunch of red flags would go up for me at the sound of that, but this might actually be worthwhile, even though the only publisher that's signed up so far is Dutton. One writer I know submitted two projects. Within a week, they had suggested revisions, and she thought they were excellent. She worked on revisions for one book and resubmitted it. It passed and she was "allowed" to send it to any number of editors at Dutton. The promise is that the approved manuscript will be read and a response will come within three weeks, although it hasn't been three weeks yet, so she doesn't know if it's true. Creative Byline is supposedly talking to other publishers.
Right now, the fees are more than reasonable. Membership to the site is currently free during their beta period. Another friend wrote them and this is what she was told: "At some point in the near future we are planning to launch additional writer services and features. At that time there will be a membership fee to belong to Creative Byline. Now (and in the future) there is a fee for submitting a manuscript: $9 for a children's picture book, and $19 for all other type of manuscripts."
I guess for me, that doesn't seem like much at all.
What do think?