aprilhenry (aprilhenry) wrote,

  • Mood:

Identical reviews - in two publications??

This review ran last month on the Web site for Publishers Weekly. This month, it's on Library Journal's. Now, I know the two publications are owned by the same company, but that just seems weird.

Has anyone else seen doubled up reviews?

I guess on the paperback the publisher can run "suspenseful tale of betrayal" - Publishers Weekly AND "an appealing, resourceful character struggling against too many odds" - Library Journal.

April Henry. Putnam, $16.99 (176p) ISBN 0-399-24385-2

Henry's (the Claire Montrose mystery series) first YA thriller is a suspenseful tale of betrayal. As the novel opens, 10th-grader Cassie is kidnapped in her own driveway as her mother and psychiatrist stepfather, Rick, not only stand by and watch, but also hand the men a suitcase. Chapters alternate from the present to the events of the past few days, during which Cassie has uncovered Rick's files about teen patients who had committed suicide while on a drug called Socom (in which he has a heavy financial investment). Consequently, Rick plants drugs in Cassie's room to convince her mother that the girl belongs in a school for troubled teens in Mexico. The place is a like a prison. Cassie and nearly 200 other teenagers are not allowed to talk; they must abide by a rigid set of dehumanizing rules, and are cruelly punished if they do not comply. The supporting characters may be two-dimensional (when Cassie's sole friend walks her home, Rick says, "Is that really the kind of young man you want to be associating with? Research shows that a child's friends can have a significant impact on academic standing and social labeling"), but the alternating chapters help to build suspense. The meat of the story is Cassie's attempt to escape. She is an appealing, resourceful character struggling against too many odds—and readers may well stick with this tale to see if she succeeds. Ages 12-up. (Feb.)

site stats
Tags: library journal, publishers weekly, shock point
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.